Butterknife Homes for Sale - Sanibel Island FL
Displayed below and updated daily from the MLS are Butterknife homes for sale, a neighborhood located in Sanibel Island, FL.
Butterknife is a small community just north of W. Gulf Dr. and home to about 35 homesites. This gated community on Sanibel Island is right across the street from Knapp's Point and the beach. Most homes are single-family properties with oversized lots and beautiful views of the preserve. It gets its name from the unique shape of the community and its main thoroughfare, Starfish Lane. The area was used during World War II as a landing strip and today, has beautiful homes, community amenities such as a swimming pool, tennis courts, and all residents have deeded beach access.
This prime location is directly across from the beach and it offers some beautiful wooded lots of more than 1/2 an acre in size. This upscale community features an easy walk from dining at nearby Casa Ybel Resort and of course, seconds to great outdoor recreation, sandy beaches, and the ocean.
For additional details on any of these homes for sale in Butterknife, just click the "Request More Information" button located on the detail page of each listing. We can provide you with disclosures, past sales history, dates and prices of homes recently sold nearby, and more.
And, for your convenience, register for a free Property Tracker account to receive email alerts whenever new Butterknife homes for sale hit the market that match your specific criteria and save your favorite properties for quick and easy access.
Get notified when matching listings become available. We also have found more listings nearby within 5 miles of this community.


The Broker providing these data believes them to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm them before relying on them in a purchase decision. Information deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.
Contact The Bell Team
- Anchors Aweigh
- Beachview CC Estates
- Belle Meade
- Betts
- Butterknife
- Castaway Estates
- Chateaux Sur Mer
- Colony Beach Estates
- Del Sega
- Dinkins Bayou
- Dunes Sanibel
- Eastwood Landing
- Ferry Landing
- Foley
- Gulf Ridge
- Gulf Ridge East
- Gumbo Limbo
- Harbour Cottage
- Herons Landing
- Island Woods
- Kearns
- Kinzie Island
- Lagoon Estates
- Las Conchas Del Mar
- Las Tiendas
- Leisure Acres
- Metes and Bounds
- Mitzi
- Palm Lake
- Palm Ridge
- Periwinkle Pines
- Periwinkle Properties
- Plantation Village
- Rocks East
- Rocks West
- Sabal Sands
- Sanctuary At Wulfert
- Sanibel Bayous
- Sanibel Center
- Sanibel Estates
- Sanibel Hamlet
- Sanibel Harbours
- Sanibel Highlands
- Sanibel Isles
- Sanibel Lake Estates
- Sanibel Pines
- Sanibel River Estates
- Sanibel Shores
- Sea Gate
- Sea Oats
- Sea Side
- Seaspray
- Shell Harbor
- Tradewinds
- Victoria Cove
- Water Shadows
- Whisperwood Cove
- White Heron
- Woodrings